Hiring Your First Head of eCommerce: The Founder’s Guide

The Digital Tonic guide to making sure your very first eCommerce hire is a success.
Stacey Currey - Recruitment Director (eCommerce & Digital)

16 Nov 2026

Digital marketing recruitment

If you’re the Founder of an eCommerce brand, one of the most important hires you’ll make as a founder is your first Head of eCommerce. Get it right and you get your evenings back while the brand grows. But, if you get it wrong, you could lose six months, a chunk of budget, and a lot of confidence.

If you’ve built your brand to this point, you’ve probably been the Head of eCommerce yourself. You know the Shopify platform inside out. You’ve been the one running the Meta ads at midnight, chased the 3PL, and written the email flows. Now the business has outgrown you doing all of it, and you know it.

I’ve spent over 10 years recruiting eCommerce and digital roles for brands across the UK. This is the stuff I wish every founder knew before they wrote that first job spec.

Are you actually ready?

Most founders hire too late, not too early. But, there are a few signs it’s genuinely time to start looking.

Signs you’re ready to hire your first Head of eCommerce:

  • You’ve become the bottleneck. Campaigns, site updates and trading decisions all wait for you, and your time is becoming overstretched.
  • Revenue has plateaued, and you can’t work out why because you’ve got no time to look properly.
  • You’re spending more time running the channel than running the business.
  • You’ve got budget for a senior salary and the marketing spend to actually do something with it.
  • You can describe what success looks like in 12 months, in numbers.
  • You have a goal of where you want the business to get to.

Signs it might be too early:

  • You can’t afford to give them a real budget. A Head of eCommerce with no spend is just an expensive executive.
  • You still want to make every decision yourself. Be honest about this one.
  • What you actually need is someone to upload products and schedule emails. That’s an eCommerce Executive or even a manager hire, and that’s fine. Not every business needs to hire a Head of eCommerce.

If you’re somewhere in the middle, a strong eCommerce Manager can be a better first step. You get someone hands-on now, and they can grow into the Head of role as you scale, and as they get to know your business.

Head of eCommerce or Head of Growth?

These titles get used interchangeably, but they’re often different jobs. Pick the wrong one and you’ll attract the wrong people.

Head of eCommerce Head of Growth
Main focus The website and online trading: conversion, merchandising, customer journey, platform Acquisition: getting new customers in, profitably
Typical background eCommerce manager or online trading Paid media, performance marketing or growth agency
Key numbers Conversion rate, AOV, revenue, margin CAC, ROAS, MER, new customer growth
Hire this if Traffic’s fine but the site isn’t converting or the trading feels chaotic The site converts well but you can’t scale traffic without losing money

In a smaller brand, your first hire will probably need to cover both. That’s normal. Just be clear in the job spec about which side matters most, because very few people are genuinely brilliant at both.

If you’ve got strong website traffic and visitors but poor conversion rates, you’ll want this person to lean more towards a traditional eCommerce role. If you’re looking to acquire more customers to your site, and you have a healthy conversion rate, then you might want to find someone more acquisition-heavy.

As a Founder-led eCommerce business making that first hire, you’ll likely benefit from those who have a blend of experience across both. The interview process is where you will want to get clear where each candidate’s experience lies.

Builder or scaler? Get this bit right

This is the most common mismatch I see. A founder hires someone with a great CV from a big brand, and six months later neither side is happy.

Someone who has run eCommerce at a £100m retailer is used to teams, agencies, big budgets and a lot of process. Your brand probably needs someone who’ll roll their sleeves up, build things from scratch and do a lot of it themselves. Working in a Founder-led brand can be scrappy and unstructured – you need to be confident that the person you’re hiring can thrive in that environment.

What tends to work for a first hire:

  • They’ve worked in a brand of a similar size, or one that was growing fast
  • They’re happy being hands-on and thinking strategically
  • They can show you numbers they personally moved, not just numbers their team moved
  • They’re comfortable with a bit of chaos and no rulebook
  • They’ll challenge you, not just agree with you

Red flags at interview:

  • Lots of “we” and not much “I”
  • Every result relied on a big budget or a big team
  • They talk about managing agencies but can’t tell you what’s actually in the ad account
  • They need a lot of structure to feel comfortable

A big-brand background isn’t a dealbreaker. Just dig into what they did with their own hands.

What should you pay?

The salary depends on your size, your location and how senior you need them to be. As a rough guide for UK brands outside London:

Level Typical salary
eCommerce Manager (hands-on, growing into the role) £40k–£55k
Senior eCommerce Manager (still hands-on but working towards Head of level) £50k–£65k
Head of eCommerce / Head of Growth £55k–£80k
Senior Head of, or Director level £75k–£95k+

A few things to think about beyond the base salary:

  • Bonus tied to growth. Revenue or profit targets work well, and they show you’re serious about the role making a difference.
  • Equity or share options. If you’re planning to scale or exit, this can win you someone you couldn’t otherwise afford. It also appeals to candidates who are excited about being involved in scaling your business.
  • Flexibility. Hybrid or remote widens your talent pool massively, especially outside the big cities.

If you go in under market, you’ll find out quickly. Good people will have other options.

Not sure what to pay, or whether it’s the right time to hire? Let’s talk it through.

Book a 15-min call

The mistakes I see founders make

  1. Hiring a unicorn. One job spec asking for paid media, SEO, CRM, Shopify development, design and team leadership. That person doesn’t exist, and if they did you couldn’t afford them.
  2. Not handing over control. You hire someone senior, then sign off every email. They’ll leave, and fairly quickly.
  3. No clear targets. If you can’t say what good looks like at 3, 6 and 12 months, neither of you will know if it’s working.
  4. Hiring a friend of a friend. It feels safe, but it often skips proper testing. It’s much harder to manage out, too.
  5. A slow process. Good eCommerce people are usually off the market within 2–3 weeks. Five interview stages over two months will lose you your best candidates.
  6. Underselling the role. Founders often forget the brand is the big draw. Tell the story: where you’ve come from, where you’re going, and why this hire matters.

How to run the hiring process

  1. Write the brief before the job spec. Spell out the 3 biggest problems you need solved, the budget they’ll control, and what success looks like in 12 months.
  2. Keep it to 2–3 stages. An intro call, a practical stage, then a final meeting with you (and your co-founder or investor, if relevant).
  3. Set a short, real task. Give them a look at your site or a trimmed-down set of your data and ask for their first 90-day plan. Keep it to a couple of hours. You’ll learn more from how they think than from any CV. Avoid asking for something that’s akin to free consultancy.
  4. Ask for specifics. “What did you change, what happened to the numbers, and what would you do differently?” eCommerce specialists are very commercial. You should expect the candidates you’re interviewing to know their numbers.
  5. Sell as hard as you assess. The best candidates are interviewing you too.
  6. Plan their first 90 days. Give them access, data and some quick wins to go after. Agree how often you’ll check in, and then give them room to get on with it.

Thinking about your first senior eCommerce hire?

The first one is the hire that shapes everything that comes after it, so it’s worth taking the time to get it right.

If you’re weighing it up, I’m always happy to have a no-pressure chat. That could be about whether it’s the right time, what the role should look like, or what you’d need to pay to get the right person. Book a call with me below and let’s talk it through.

Stacey Currey, Recruitment Director at Digital Tonic

Written by

Stacey Currey

Recruitment Director & Co-founder, Digital Tonic

Stacey has spent over 10 years recruiting eCommerce, paid media and digital marketing talent for brands and agencies across the UK, from first hires to Head of level.

Book a call
Connect on LinkedIn

Recent Posts

View all